📢 Last Call Standards Track: ERC

ERC-1191: Add chain id to mixed-case checksum address encoding

Authors	Juliano Rizzo (@juli)
Created	2018-03-18
Last Call Deadline	2019-11-18
Requires	EIP-55, EIP-155

This EIP is in the process of being peer-reviewed. If you are interested in this EIP, please participate using this discussion link.

Simple Summary
Abstract
Motivation
Specification
Rationale
Implementation
Test Cases
Usage
- Usage Table
- Implementation Table
Copyright

Simple Summary

This EIP extends EIP-55 by optionally adding a chain id defined by EIP-155 to the checksum calculation.

Abstract

The EIP-55 was created to prevent users from losing funds by sending them to invalid addresses. This EIP extends EIP-55 to protect users from losing funds by sending them to addresses that are valid but that where obtained from a client of another network.For example, if this EIP is implemented, a wallet can alert the user that is trying to send funds to an Ethereum Testnet address from an Ethereum Mainnet wallet.

Motivation

The motivation of this proposal is to provide a mechanism to allow software to distinguish addresses from different Ethereum based networks. This proposal is necessary because Ethereum addresses are hashes of public keys and do not include any metadata. By extending the EIP-55 checksum algorithm it is possible to achieve this objective.

Specification

Convert the address using the same algorithm defined by EIP-55 but if a registered chain id is provided, add it to the input of the hash function. If the chain id passed to the function belongs to a network that opted for using this checksum variant, prefix the address with the chain id and the 0x separator before calculating the hash. Then convert the address to hexadecimal, but if the ith digit is a letter (ie. it’s one of abcdef) print it in uppercase if the 4*ith bit of the calculated hash is 1 otherwise print it in lowercase.

Rationale

Benefits:

By means of a minimal code change on existing libraries, users are protected from losing funds by mixing addresses of different Ethereum based networks.

Implementation

#!/usr/bin/python3
from sha3 import keccak_256
import random
"""
   addr (str): Hexadecimal address, 40 characters long with 2 characters prefix
   chainid (int): chain id from EIP-155 """
def eth_checksum_encode(addr, chainid=1):
    adopted_eip1191 = [30, 31]
    hash_input = str(chainid) + addr.lower() if chainid in adopted_eip1191 else addr[2:].lower()
    hash_output = keccak_256(hash_input.encode('utf8')).hexdigest()
    aggregate = zip(addr[2:].lower(),hash_output)
    out = addr[:2] + ''.join([c.upper() if int(a,16) >= 8 else c for c,a in aggregate])
    return out

Test Cases

eth_mainnet = [
"0x27b1fdb04752bbc536007a920d24acb045561c26",
"0x3599689E6292b81B2d85451025146515070129Bb",
"0x42712D45473476b98452f434e72461577D686318",
"0x52908400098527886E0F7030069857D2E4169EE7",
"0x5aAeb6053F3E94C9b9A09f33669435E7Ef1BeAed",
"0x6549f4939460DE12611948b3f82b88C3C8975323",
"0x66f9664f97F2b50F62D13eA064982f936dE76657",
"0x8617E340B3D01FA5F11F306F4090FD50E238070D",
"0x88021160C5C792225E4E5452585947470010289D",
"0xD1220A0cf47c7B9Be7A2E6BA89F429762e7b9aDb",
"0xdbF03B407c01E7cD3CBea99509d93f8DDDC8C6FB",
"0xde709f2102306220921060314715629080e2fb77",
"0xfB6916095ca1df60bB79Ce92cE3Ea74c37c5d359",
]
rsk_mainnet = [
"0x27b1FdB04752BBc536007A920D24ACB045561c26",
"0x3599689E6292B81B2D85451025146515070129Bb",
"0x42712D45473476B98452f434E72461577d686318",
"0x52908400098527886E0F7030069857D2E4169ee7",
"0x5aaEB6053f3e94c9b9a09f33669435E7ef1bEAeD",
"0x6549F4939460DE12611948B3F82B88C3C8975323",
"0x66F9664f97f2B50F62d13EA064982F936de76657",
"0x8617E340b3D01Fa5f11f306f4090fd50E238070D",
"0x88021160c5C792225E4E5452585947470010289d",
"0xD1220A0Cf47c7B9BE7a2e6ba89F429762E7B9adB",
"0xDBF03B407c01E7CD3cBea99509D93F8Dddc8C6FB",
"0xDe709F2102306220921060314715629080e2FB77",
"0xFb6916095cA1Df60bb79ce92cE3EA74c37c5d359",
]
rsk_testnet = [
"0x27B1FdB04752BbC536007a920D24acB045561C26",
"0x3599689e6292b81b2D85451025146515070129Bb",
"0x42712D45473476B98452F434E72461577D686318",
"0x52908400098527886E0F7030069857D2e4169EE7",
"0x5aAeb6053F3e94c9b9A09F33669435E7EF1BEaEd",
"0x6549f4939460dE12611948b3f82b88C3c8975323",
"0x66f9664F97F2b50f62d13eA064982F936DE76657",
"0x8617e340b3D01fa5F11f306F4090Fd50e238070d",
"0x88021160c5C792225E4E5452585947470010289d",
"0xd1220a0CF47c7B9Be7A2E6Ba89f429762E7b9adB",
"0xdbF03B407C01E7cd3cbEa99509D93f8dDDc8C6fB",
"0xDE709F2102306220921060314715629080e2Fb77",
"0xFb6916095CA1dF60bb79CE92ce3Ea74C37c5D359",
]
test_cases = {30 : rsk_mainnet, 31 : rsk_testnet, 1 : eth_mainnet}

for chainid, cases in test_cases.items():
    for addr in cases:
        assert ( addr == eth_checksum_encode(addr,chainid) )

Usage

Usage Table

Network	Chain id	Supports this EIP
RSK Mainnet	30	Yes
RSK Testnet	31	Yes

Implementation Table

Project	EIP Usage	Implementation
MyCrypto	Yes	JavaScript
MyEtherWallet	Yes	JavaScript
Ledger	Yes	C
Trezor	Yes	Python and C
Web3.js	Yes	JavaScript
EthereumJS-util	Yes	JavaScript
ENS address-encoder	Yes	TypeScript

Copyright

Citation

Please cite this document as:

Juliano Rizzo (@juli), "ERC-1191: Add chain id to mixed-case checksum address encoding [DRAFT]," Ethereum Improvement Proposals, no. 1191, March 2018. [Online serial]. Available: https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-1191.